Barry Siegel turns his writing in the fiction direction with his
first novel, The Perfect Witness. An award-winning reporter
for the Los Angeles Times, Siegel was nominated for an
Edgar award in the Best Fact Crime category for one of his two previous
books, A Death in White Bear Lake. Billed as a courtroom
thriller, The Perfect Witness provides a perfect opportunity
for readers to watch with a critical eye how a true crime writer fares
in making the jump from factual to fictive material.
Greg Monarch practices civil law in the central California coastal
town of La Graciosa. His one turn at capital criminal defense landed
his client on Death Row. On his own since his former partner, Ira
Sullivan, lost his grip on living after the death of his young son,
Greg works cases of little controversy, sticking to the strict ethical
code he inherited from his physician father. When Ira stands accused
of the brutal murder of an elderly postmaster, Greg tries to refuse the
job of Ira's defense counsel. He finds that he simply cannot stand
idly by while the man who was once his best friend is tried for a crime
Ira maintains he did not commit.
Trouble is, Ira can't account for his own whereabouts for the time
of the murder. The last thing he remembers is heading for the dunes
with a couple of bar buddies, after which he blacked out from a combination
of booze and meth. A bullet from a .38 killed the postmaster, and Ira
owns a .38. The fact that ballistics indicate that it wasn't Ira's gun,
but a similar one, from which the fatal shot was fired, and the fact that
there are no fingerprints or fibers on the scene to indicate Ira's
presence, become moot points in the case. The ambitious man prosecuting
Ira has an undeniable ace in the hole: an acquaintance of Ira's who
says she was with him at the postmaster's and saw Ira kill the old man.
She is unflappable and convincing. She is the perfect witness.
Goaded into helping his old friend by newspaper reporter Jimmy O'Brien,
Greg cannot surmount Sandy Polson's testimony against Ira. Ira is convicted
of first-degree murder and sentenced to death. With the reluctant help of Assistant
U.S. District Attorney Kim Rosen, Greg will uncover a conspiracy to bury Ira
with roots in a local power plant's criminal disposal of nuclear
waste. He will discover a whole invisible social strata revolving around
the dunes of central California. Neither will be enough to get his
friend off Death Row. What he must do is walk down the path of
understanding the sociopathic mind, a walk that will take him across
his personal ethical lines and into a realization that shatters his
belief in the person upon whose ethics he has modeled his own. He must
make the perfect witness his own.
The Perfect Witness starts off with the promise of being
an intriguing literary/thriller cross. It loses some steam about
midway, but has enough momentum to carry the reader through to its
conclusion. The Perfect Witness is not the perfect book,
but with practice and time its author might just come to rival the
mighty Grisham.