Family becomes more important to most of us as we age, as does the
necessity to forgive and become more tolerant. Letty Cottin Pogrebin's
first novel, Three Daughters, follows three sisters' lives and their
relationships with their rabbi father and each other. It concerns the power of love, faith and forgiveness, the negative and
positive aspects of middle age and menopause, and the resilience of the
human soul.
The three sisters have the same father, but two different mothers. They
have all married and borne children, although in all other ways the
women couldn't have less in common. Leah is a radical feminist scholar,
married to a gentle artist. She is not a religious Jew. Rachel practices
her father's religion more than her siblings. Married to a chilly
lawyer, she is the richest but the least fulfilled. To contribute to
the family's income, Rachel creates needlepoint pillows and plaques. The
youngest, Shoshanna, is married to her soulmate, Daniel, a scholar. She
is a professional runner of errands and organizer of events for
others. The chapters alternate between the three sisters' points of
view.
Starting with Shoshanna, the book pulls you in immediately, especially
if you are middle-aged as she is, about to turn 50. Her appointment
book blows off the hood of her car and its pages scatter across a
major highway. She has no idea what she has scheduled for the next day
or for two months later. Without her book, she will forget several
birthdays. The one thing she knows, with pride and anticipation, is that
her father, Sam Wasserman, pushing 90, is coming back to New York from
Israel to receive a prestigious award. Her older sister Leah has been
estranged from him for more than four decades, and everyone wants that
situation to change, somehow.
In Three Sisters, the relationships are realistically complex and the
characters very late '90s. A gay couple has been joined in a civil
ceremony; a depressed man goes over the edge; one divorce occurs; one
woman's child is in jail.
I heartily enjoyed this novel except for two slight things. Perhaps
because I read it slowly, over a week, it took quite awhile to sort out
the ages of the sisters and their relationships to their father. Two or
three half-day sittings in which to read the thick novel might work
better, given the luxury of free time. And the book is peppered with
Yiddish words, many of which I didn't know. This is both good and bad. I
did learn a lot about the culture, but I sometimes felt confused.
However, with grace, the author explains some of them for her shiksa, or
non-New York readers.
Here's an example of the latter:
"She'd [Shoshanna] inherited her
mother's kaynahoras, the crazy fears about having too much, the
obligation to be grateful for the good stuff but not to get smug or
showy lest she attract people's envy, which would attract the Evil Eye,
which would strike her with some horrible affliction to cut her down to
size."
Pogrebin has written eight other books, including her memoir, Getting
Over Getting Older. She is one of four co-founders of the Ms. Foundation
for Women (in the novel, Leah runs a feminist magazine), and she
lectures on Jewish issues, feminism and the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict. This is an intelligent and engrossing book combining many of
the author's interests and offering insight into growing old with grace and
wisdom.