Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies
richly deserves the 1998 Pulitzer prize for general nonfiction it
garnered. A thorough and compelling study of the reasons behind the
dominance of select cultures throughout humanity's history, this book
written by a professor of physiology at the UCLA School of Medicine is
tremendously accessible to the layperson. Diamond, who is also preeminent
in the arenas of evolutionary biology and biogeography, presents a
straightforward explanation for the diversity of human fates that is
soundly supported by information from many fields of scientific inquiry.
Perhaps the most notable feat Guns, Germs, and Steel
accomplishes is that of providing a far more persuasive explanation for
ethnic and racial differences than can racist theories (like the recently
controversial Bell Curve) of human history. Broad in scope,
Diamond's book covers 13,000 years of humanity's past over the entire
world. While no single continent or society is covered to its greatest
depth, Australia, New Guinea and New Zealand provide the greatest amount of anecdotal
illustration, since Diamond spent a number of years in the region engaged
in scientific study. Diamond does an admirable job of representing the
macrocosm by the microcosm, making his theory of history palatable to
the general reader.
How did Eurasians come to conquer Native Americans, Africans and Aboriginal
Australians instead of the other way around? The answer, according to
Jared Diamond, lies with four basic sets of innate differences in the environments from
which different peoples arose. Arguing that food production is critical
for a society to feed non-food-producing specialists and a larger population
that would have a military advantage of sheer numbers, Diamond illustrates
the inequitable distribution of domesticable plants and animals around
the world. A second set of factors affected the greatly differing rates
of diffusion and migration on the different continents. Eurasia, with
its east-west major axis and modest geographical and ecological barriers,
saw a far quicker rate of diffusion of domesticated food sources, diseases
and technologies than did Africa and the Americas, with their north-south
major axes. A third set of factors affected diffusion and migration
between continents; the varying degrees of isolation between land masses
has greatly affected the diffusion rates. And a fourth set of factors,
consisting of differences in area and total population size between the
continents, affects the pressure put on societies to adopt and retain
innovations, or be subsumed by their neighbors.
The "guns, germs, and steel" of the book's title refer to weapons,
diseases, and technologies, whose development and spread are to a great
extent dependent on the four sets of factors Diamond summarizes as
responsible for history's broadest patterns. At the base of Diamond's
pyramidal argument is food production, and he makes a stellar case
for history being driven by chance facts of geography, a story of "haves"
and "havenots" in terms of suitable environments rather than an indication
of genetic superiors and inferiors. Readable and plain-spoken, Guns,
Germs, and Steel will fascinate anyone interested in the history
of humans on this peculiar little planet.